Torturous Comedy
(Also on AO3 Here)
(Disclaimer: I am not a comedian, but I tried my best.)
Garak never could have predicted the line of work his precocious daughter would have gone into. She had been a sharp writer, an artist, and a bit of a loner all through her schooling (a fact, Garak knew, Julian blamed himself for, concerned it was the xenophobic sentiment on Cardassia that kept their lovely daughter from gaining friends on the planet).
Privately, Garak thinks it had more to do with his daughter’s alarming sense of humor. A mixture of Julian’s tart sarcasm, and Garak’s love of theatricality, Mila often says things that were just so slightly off-color.
Still- a comedian. The first Cardassian Comedian. And to make matters much, much worse, she was actually funny.
True, much of his comedy was based on her parents, but certainly, who could blame her? Garak thinks fatalistically. A tailor and a spy as one father and a super-doctor as the other, Mila certainly had her reasons for psychological trauma.
Julian, he knows, handles the state of affairs by being relentlessly supportive. He sends Mila dozens of leading publications on attracting larger crowds at venues (a facet of his personality that translates on stage to a neurotically protective parent). He attempts to go to as many shows as his busy schedule reasonably accommodates. When news outlets reach out to ask him for comment, he only ever utters glowing praise of his “brilliant daughter,” who is so “tremendously clever and funny.”
But in the privacy of their home, Julian will badger Garak relentlessly on the apparent psychological damage they dealt their child.
Garak is often quick to point out that any errors they made along the way are too long in the past to be corrected. At least Mila can use her childhood trauma for creative gain.
And, she does still speak to them. She calls regularly, she still tells them about her life, she is still their daughter.
Still- he could do without:
“So, you think your parents are bad?” Mila says, asking the audience, who cheers slightly.
“My parents are… what’s a polite way to say it? Sexually active? Fucking like bunnies? Do you know how shitty it is to be in your twenties and know that your parents are fucking more than you?”
The audience laughs while she continues, “and of course, it doesn’t help that my human father cannot help but discuss his storied youth” here, she drops into an uncanny impression of Julian’s accent. “Oh darling, when I was your age, I used to have these incredible threesomes with my Vulcan roommate and an Orion. But so lovely to hear that you had a nice date with Simon, my human boyfriend and civilian geologist. We’re getting married in the spring.”
The audience laughs and cheers in congratulations.
“I’m the nerd in the family. My parents fuck and commit treason, and I’m stuck doing math homework and going to bed every night at nine. I could tell them about the party drugs I did last night, and they say, "make sure you always have a phaser.”
The audience laughs.
“What’s worse is I think they’re being serious!” She takes a swig of water.
The show continues, the audience laughing and cheering appropriately when Garak appears in his daughter’s dressing room. He knows she hadn’t been aware he was in the audience, and she certainly hadn’t been aware that Garak had her private security key, but if she didn’t realize these facts by now, he had raised an idiot.
“Yadik,” Mila says, barely reacting despite her apparent surprise. Garak smiles proudly.
“The audience liked you,” Garak says.
“You’ve never come to a show before,” she says. And this is true. Garak had only ever heard about her performances second-hand from Julian.
Garak quarks an eyebrow ridge instead, “are you quite certain of that, young lady?”
Mila laughs slightly under her breath, turns, and hugs him. “It is good to see you, Yadik.”
“Your father is concerned,” Garak replies lightly.
“Dad is always concerned,” she says with a rolled eye.
Garak gives her a stern look, “Mila.”
“Sorry,” she says, looking contrite.
Garak was fanatical about the language she used to describe her parents in person. Garak privately wonders how much she realizes this is to protect Julian, who faced such constant disrespect on Cardassia despite his overwhelming value and brilliance. Garak guesses she’s more aware than he wishes she were.
“You have a good stage presence,” he says instead.
“Thank you,” she says and then hesitates before continuing with, “you don’t like what I do, do you?”
“It is not in my nature,” Garak starts, cautiously, “to want details of my private family life, no matter how exaggerated, to be shared publicly. However, I know you are passionate about this. And talented at it. And I am, despite my misgivings, glad to see you so in your element. I suppose it is not so terribly different from my work in the Obsidian Order.”
“Oh?” she says archly, looking so much like Julian with the twinkle in her eye. “Pray tell, how? How exactly is comedy at all like torture?”
“Well, of course, both comedy and torture are about manipulation. The precise choice of words and actions at the right moment. I suppose, in the end, you took much more after me than either of us ever could have anticipated.”
She looks at him in disbelief for a few moments longer before breaking down into hysterical laughter. “At least I know I’ll never run out of material.”
Garak smiles fondly, gazing at the young woman in front of him. Clever, brave, independent, and fiercely affectionate. He thinks about how she looked on stage, sparkling in the stage lights.
He hadn’t been expecting to like his grown-up daughter this much. Love? Certainly. But she had grown into such an interesting and dynamic young lady that he thinks even if he didn’t raise her, he would have wanted to know her.
And then he thinks, quite unbidden, that he and Julian really did a wonderful job.
He shakes his head slightly and says, “I am in town overnight, and- if you are willing to spare a few moments away from your party drugs- I would love to take you to dinner.”
She smiles brilliantly. “I would love that.”
“Wonderful. I cannot wait to hear more of your impression of your dad. You really have quite captured his intonation, and I do so miss him. He’s been in the gamma quadrant for three weeks now.”
She laughs slightly again. “I can always use the practice”
He lets her guide them out of their changing room and feels, deep in his core, despite how different she was than anything he had imagined, deeply proud of the woman leading him.