Dumbass time travelers out here not realising that they’re actually Hitler’s dad until it’s too late.
Or how about raising Hitler to be a well-adjusted human being? Or if that’s too much, how about replacing the director of the art school and then accept Hitler?
Hitler’s biggest problem wasn’t the memetic art school, it’s the trauma he got as a survivor of WWI + the drastic state of the Weimar Republic’s economy post WWI + centuries of antisemitic attitudes being built into the then-contemporary German society + rise of the banks following early globalization, Great Depression and other wacky events while the banks were mainly Jewish-owned due to Christians largely considered banking beneath them.
So does this mean if Hitler didn’t become dictator then someone else would have taken his place given those circumstances?
Yeah, very likely either the NSDAP would’ve formed anyway with another crazy asshole at the helm or communists would’ve won and did genocide and conquering independently.
Jung described Hitler as “Germany’s shadow” and he was, he didn’t have a coherent Ideology when he stepped up and held his beer hall speeches. He spoke and was influenced by how the people there reacted to his words, so he was moulded by the sentiment of the masses into what he later became.
Also fascism and German Fascism formed independent of Hitler. If anything Hitler simply co-opted an already existing movement and to put himself at the head.
As far as antisemitism goes, you must remember that it wasn’t the Nazis who came up with the scape-goating, it was the Prussian aristocracy and Wilhelm II that created and pushed the “stabbed in the back” narrative to shift blame away from their botched handling of WW1 and refusal to end things earlier on much better terms.
A very good addition
WWII and events leading to it are much more complex than people usually think
World War II is the subject of countless movies, documentaries, books, and media, but World War I and its aftermath’s effect on the roots of World War II is generally less publicized. Which is a crying shame, because you can draw a direct throughline from the Treaty of Versailles to a lot of the chaos of the 20th century and beyond, including World War II, the Middle East, and more.
The weirdest thing I realized in history class was that if France wasn’t such an asshole after ww1, ww2 would have never happened. Because they intentionally went into the treaty demanding that Germany be eternally crippled for the horrible crime of beating them.
Hitler was an incredibly evil person who did incalculable damage to the lives and cultures of humanity… but if it weren’t him, it would have been somebody else. He was a product of the situation, not the other way around. The general population of germany already felt like they were being cheated and oppressed, already blamed Jews and foreigners for all their problems, and was already just about ready to start trying to take back what they felt they deserved by force.
And while it’s possible that a sufficiently dedicated and charismatic hero could have defused that powder keg before it went off, and if there were a few more years before the inciting incident the international community could have done something to fix the situation, I think it’s very unlikely that either of those possibilities would have happened given that nobody was making the slightest move in that direction before the angry mob chose their figurehead.
And that’s the crucial lesson about WWII that everybody tries so very hard to forget. It’s easy to think of Hitler as some sort of supernatural force of evil, or some uniquely brilliant genius strategist, or a totally inhuman monster, because then you can tell yourself that it won’t happen again until another unstoppable supervillain appears out of nowhere. It’s hard to accept that he wasn’t anything special. Rather below average actually, which was fortunate for the rest of the world since a leader who was smarter would have done a lot more damage. And that means that any moron could become the next hitler. All it takes is a population who feels that they’ve been cheated, who wants to engage in violence against The Other to take revenge for perceived oppression.






