sora-baggins:

Whovians: I skipped nine.

Potterheads: They’re just books.

Tolkienites: Why didn’t the eagles just drop them off?

Merlinians: You must have known it was going to end like that.

Hunters: I skipped the first three seasons to meet cas.

Sherlockians: I hate Mrs Hudson.

Hiddlestoners or Cumberbabes: But he is ugly.

All fandoms: Its not real. Its only a stupid story.

I have to admit that I am a Tolkienite, and I think that video is hilarious. There are plenty of complicated reasons that the eagles couldn’t (or wouldn’t) just fly Frodo to Mordor, but otoh I can see from an outsider’s point of view that it seems like such an obvious fix. Tolkien does have a tendency to write his characters into such tight corners that only the eagles can save them.

So you can ask me why they didn’t just ride the eagles to Mordor. You just probably will regret you asked about three paragraphs into the explanation.