drst:
i’m going to start off slow.
i’m furious.
i’m a young jewish woman, and i deserve to be treated with basic fucking decency. i should be able to relax and enjoy my holiday, say shanah tovah and not have to deal with goyische bullshit.
for those of you who haven’t heard, this years cw superhero supercrossover fuckdome is entitled “crisis on earth x”. earth x is the earth of the CWSeed’s new animated show The Ray, where canonically jewish characters/jewish coded characters such as barry allen, ray palmer, and kara zor el along with multiple other superheroes are nazis. i’m not going to explain why this is gross because you have google right at your fingertips.
comic books are jewish american culture. that’s right, say it with me. COMIC BOOKS ARE JEWISH AMERICAN CULTURE. every classic comic superhero you love was created by jews and tells a jewish story. batman? jewish. superman? jewish. wonderwoman? jewish. every single one of them tells a jewish story.
by making these characters nazis, they turn our own creations against us. we contributed to society, but they’d rather see a world where we’re dead than one where they give us credit for everything we’ve contributed.
so here’s the deal: don’t watch the crossover live. don’t give them the ratings. if you’re really despesrate, but the seasons on amazon or something and watch it right after it airs. watch it illegally online. don’t give them the ratings, let them know that this isn’t ok.
yell on social media. tweet the dctv writers. be vocal about how ugly this is. do something this is so bad please protect ur local jews.
So so far we have this clusterfuck AND the “Arrow” writers (all white folks) wanting to do an episode about Black Lives Matter.
And the season hasn’t started yet. YIKES.
Are we surprised though? Arrow writers put Jewish Fe in a gas chamber and Marvel tried to make Captain “I hate nazis” America into a nazi.
Lately, comic writers have not treated minorities well at all. It’s like they don’t know that not all of their audience is made up of WASPs.
Also, and this couldn’t matter less, but OP mentioned Kara Zor-El being coded as Jewish, which I am having trouble understanding because she’s literally an alien.
I’m not saying that it’s wrong, simply that I missed the part where that happened. If someone could explain that to me, I would really appreciate it.
To quote some articles on Superman (and Kara by association, given they’re family members):
“Superman was created in the 1930s by writer Jerry Siegel and artist Joe Shuster, two Jewish-American children of European refugees. Superman’s “old country” is Krypton, an advanced realm that ultimately destroyed itself. Superman’s real name is Kal-El, son of Jor-El. The suffix El, of course, means “of God” in Hebrew, with Kal-El defined by some as “Voice of God.” Before Krypton’s doom, Kal-El’s parents put him in a Moses-like basket, sending him down the Nile of intergalactic space until he landed safely on Earth.There, in the most goyische place ever (a farm in Kansas!) Kal-El assumes the secret identity of Clark Kent, and this “model minority” soon thrives in his new environment. The yellow sun’s radiation provides a source for him to “leap tall buildings in a single bound,” though for Siegel and Shuster it was meant to symbolize the freedom from pogroms and Nazism which allowed them to find safety and success.” - Times of Israel
“Faced with the threat of imminent death to their beloved infant son, his parents launched him out into the unknown and toward an unknowable fate in a specially-constructed craft in a desperate last-ditch attempt to save his life. Cast adrift from a society on the brink of extinction, he grew up in an alien culture to be a hero, a leader for all time who achieved great feats beyond even the imagination of his people.No, not Moses. Superman.Commentators often link Superman’s roots to both the Jewish immigrant experience and the Exodus account of Moses. …
The story begins with two young American Jews, Jerry Siegel (1914-1996) and Joe Shuster (1914-1992) who, deeply troubled by their sense of Jewish powerlessness in the face of rising anti-Semitism at home and overseas, created Superman, a fabled character who reflected their own Jewish values. In fact, from the very beginning Superman was created to help fight Hitler and the Nazis. …
Superman’s birth name is Kal-El, which means either “voice of God” or “God is all.” His adopted name came from Thus Spoke Zarathustra, in which Nietzsche introduces the concept of Superman (“Ubermensch“), the hero who transcends what Nietzsche considered the enslavement of Christian morality by his “will to power.”Superman’s father warned his people of the imminent destruction of their planet but he was ignored, much as those who forecast the impending European Holocaust were ignored – and, as a result, the people of Krypton and the Jews of Europe were both exterminated.
Superman and Moses were each adopted by non-Jewish parents, who quickly understood just how extraordinary were their abandoned babies. Much as Moses, Superman eventually used powers “beyond those of mortal man” to save his people; he dedicated himself to fight for “truth and justice” – tzedek, tzedek tirdof – and, lest we forget, “the American Way;” and his life epitomizes the concept of tikkun olam.Much as Moses kept secret his Jewish identity while growing up in the house of Pharaoh, Superman, the alien-born assimilationist-survivor who left his planetary shtetl and escapes to America, hid his “otherness” and heroic qualities behind the alter ego of a bespectacled nebbish.
And there is more. Much as Eretz Yisrael, the eternal homeland of the Jewish people, has continued to exercise its pull on Jews throughout their centuries in the Diaspora, Superman could never forget his homeland, in part because the remnants of his home planet constitute his only Achilles heel: “Kryptonite.”Superman’s yearning for the land of his ancestors is analogous to the longing of the Jews to return to the land God promised them, and the respect he continues to feel for his departed biological parents, along with his desire to honor their memories through the performance of good deeds, could have come right out of our Torah.” - Jewish press
“Along with the web content, Dr. Craig Detweiller, Ph.D. of Theology and Culture, wrote a nine page essay titled “Jesus–The Original Superhero” to specifically link the Last Son of Krypton with the Son of God. Detweiller cited the oft repeated evidence about the suffix “el” appending Superman’s Kryptonian birth name “Kal-el.” In Hebrew, the “el” suffix is used to denote Elohim, or Yahweh, Jehovah, or God, like in the names Michael, Ariel, and Raphael. In his essay, Detweiller also referenced the Jochebedian orphanization Superman suffered as his parents, forewarned of the planet Krypton’s imminent demise, shot their baby into outer space like a futuristic Moses.But if comparing Superman to Jesus was meant to “Christianize” the hero, they might have picked a better candidate. Jesus was a Jew, the last supper was a Passover meal, and every minor prophet has a miracle or two tucked up their sleeve. Jonah lived in a whale.Orphaned at birth to protect him from a world destroying cataclysm, the Man of Steel is most often compared to Moses because they were both raised by non-Jewish families and eventually accessed magic powers to save their tribe. Also presented as evidence are the similarities between the S symbol on Superman’s chest and the Hebrew character Lamedh. Larry Tye, author of Superman: The High-Flying History of America’s Most Enduring Hero, compared Superman’s code of ethics—“Truth, Justice, and the American Way”—to the Mishnaic values of “truth, peace, and justice.”” - The Daily beast
And this tumblr post notes on how Supergirl/Kara reflects Miriam, in the same vein Superman/Kal reflects Moses.
I’ve read much more about Superman’s Jewish links, but I’m 100% sure the same things that can be said for him can be said for Supergirl. Both are Jewish-coded characters. Like, yeah…both are aliens…that doesn’t mean they can’t be Jewish-coded, especially when their creation came about during a time when Jewish people were seen and treated as aliens, and were experiencing widespread diaspora.
Ok this is disgusting. Also like… did he not learn anything from Marvel’s shit show?